Pie Sensations

Reviews about Pie Sensations

• 1 / 5

  By Nana Deb
  Tried the overpriced caramel & key lime pies. Both had bland flavors that were not sweet at all. O'Charley's caramel puts this to shame. The key lime had no punch of the tart flavor its known for, instead having almost a spiced pumpkin taste. Disappointed. Won't go back. : (
  March 13, 2017
• 4 / 5

  By Matthew Snow
  Pretty good selection of pies. They had a peanut butter and chocolate one I really liked!
  November 28, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Liberty Stump
  Update 1 year later- as delicious as ever! I love that they have cupcakes, cookies, caramels and fudge- lots of little sweets to eat when you stop in to grab a pie or cake for your family gathering. Atmosphere is clean and cozy. Sweet employees and beautiful decor. They partner with lots of area artists, businesses and organizations as well. This place is definitely a community staple!
  
  Original Review: Loooove this cute little pie shop! Family owned and operated, they make a huuuge assortment of pies and sweets- all of them delicious. My personal favorite is the Dutch Apple pie, with Banana Cream Pie a close second. They also have homemade seasonal items- whoopie pies, toffee, caramels, and fried pies. Make it a point to visit this gem the next time you're in the area! You won't regret it!
  September 10, 2016
• 1 / 5

  By hdb80
  I was in Pie Sensations for the first time about a month ago. Being new to the area we had heard of this place and decided to stop in for a slice of pie. Upon entering I was charmed with the design and decor of the shop (reminded me of the movie Mary Poppins), but that is where the charm began and ended.
  
  When we approached the counter a middle aged woman yelled from the back if she could help us, she reluctantly left the kitchen to help us and we could tell she was none too pleased to have customers. We asked for a menu and she pointed to a sign, then informed us that "we don't have anything in stock right now. Ask and I'll let you know if we have it." Well...there are about 100 different pies. It would have been nice to be informed of what you do and don't have before I rattle off 100 different pies! Besides, if you're busy making pie and have nothing, then WHY are you open to the public for service?!
  
  We settled on the first pie she said they had, we couldn't even make a choice with the info she gave us (which was nothing). When the pie was ready she stood at the counter and said, "here you go" and left it there. We got up to get it ourselves and there were no forks. When asked about the fork and a napkin she pointed from behind a window in the kitchen. At more than $5 a slice, the least you could do is inform me where to get a fork, lady.
  
  Over all the pie was very mediocre. I didn't finish it, took the rest home and later threw it away. I could have made the pie myself in 10 minutes at home, so not worth the money. I was very put out by the customer service. At the end of the day, if you're that put off by customers then you should not be in business at all. And if you have no inventory to sell, then close your doors until you do. This shop is either owned or run by very business incompetent people. I had hopes to use this shop for holidays and such, but I'll never go back. The treatment alone, regardless of the pie, is enough to keep me away.
  
  Scathing review? Yes. Did Pie Sensations deserve it? Absolutely.
  June 25, 2016